Shift Left Testing Vs Shift Right Testing
In this article, you will learn difference between Shift Left Testing vs Shift Right Testing.
The concepts of shift left and shift right are integral part of the agile DevOps methodology.
To keep software quality high in ever-changing environments, DevOps teams are adopting shift-left and shift-right principles.
What is Shift Left Testing?
Shift Left Testing is a term used in the software testing industry that refers to moving the focus of testing earlier in the development process.
Shift Left Testing is also sometimes referred to as Early Testing, Early Shift.
The goal of Shift Left Testing is to find and fix defects as early in the development process as possible.
Don’t miss: Shift Left Testing – Definition, Benefits, Challenes
What is Shift Right Testing?
Shift Right Testing is a term used in the software testing industry that refers to moving the focus of testing later in the development process.
Shift Right Testing is also sometimes referred to as Late Testing, Late Shift.
The goal of Shift Right Testing is to find and fix defects as close to release as possible.
Don’t miss: Shift Right Testing – Definition, Benefits, Challenes
Does Shift Right Replace Shift Left?
No. Shift Right Testing does not replace Shift Left Testing, but rather it is complementary to Shift Left Testing.
Both shift right and shift left testing are important for giving users a positive experience on your website or app.
Both Shift Left and Shift Right Testing have their advantages and disadvantages, which are listed below.
Advantages of Shift Left Testing
- Finding and fixing defects earlier in the development process can save time and money
- Earlier feedback can help improve the quality of the software product
- Finding defects early can help prevent them from propagating to other parts of the codebase
Disadvantages of Shift Left Testing
- Can slow down the development process if not managed properly
- Requires additional training for developers
- Can be difficult to implement in legacy systems
Advantages of Shift Right Testing
- Finding and fixing defects closer to release can help prevent major issues from going live
- Can catch issues that were not found in earlier testing stages
Disadvantages of Shift Right Testing
- Waiting until later in the development process to test can be more expensive
- Can lead to schedule delays if many defects are found close to release
Shift Left Testing vs Shift Right Testing: Which is Better?
There is no definitive answer to this question, as the best approach for your software project depends on a variety of factors.
However, in general, Shift Left Testing is considered to be more advantageous than Shift Right Testing.
This is because Shift Left Testing can help save time and money by finding and fixing defects earlier in the development process.
In addition, Shift Left Testing can help improve the quality of the software product by providing early feedback to developers.
While Shift Right Testing has its own advantages, it is generally less effective than Shift Left Testing and should only be used in complement to Shift Left Testing.
| Shift-Left Testing | Shift-Right Testing |
|---|---|
| Shifting left means moving all tasks related to test execution to the left on in a software’s development timeline. | Shifting right means moving all tasks related to test execution to the right on in a software’s development timeline. |
| The term "shifting left" means that critical tests are done more frequently throughout the software design and development process, rather than waiting until the end when it's too late to make changes. | The term "shifting right" means that monitoring user behavior, performance and security metrics, as well as experimenting with Chaos Engineering to test a system's resistance levels. |
| Aim is to find problems early. | Aim is to find how resistant the application is. |
| Practice of performing testing early in the development life cycle. | Practice of performing testing at the end of the development life cycle (i.e., in production). |
| Shift-left testing is performed early in the software application's lifecycle, it goes hand-in-hand with the development process. | Shift right testing is performed in the post deployment in the life cycle (end of the development life cycle), the testing is performed in the production environment. |
| Testers perform shift left tests to identify and fix bugs as early as possible in the development pipeline to avoid errors. | Testers perform shift right tests to identify and fix bugs as early as possible in the deployment pipeline to enhance user experience. |
| Shift-left moves the testing process, quality, and performance evaluation early in the software development process. | Shift-right moves the testing process, quality, and performance evaluation in the production environment under real-world conditions. |
| It speeds up development efficiency and reduces costs as it detects and addresses bugs earlier in the development cycle before they get to production. | It ensure that applications running in production can withstand real user load while ensuring the quality of the application. |
| By adopting a "shift left" mentality, QA teams can proactively identify issues and problems early on in the development process, before it's too late to make changes. This allows developers to address potential challenges without succumbing to the pressures of an upcoming deadline. Additionally, "shift left" saves money by identifying and resolving errors sooner rather than later. | By adopting a "shift right" mentality, QA teams perform software testing at the end of the development cycle, also known as testing in production. This approach allows developers to find new and unexpected scenarios that may have gone undetected in development environments. |
| By shifting left, developers and testers are able to work more effectively together. | By shifting right, testers and Ops teams are able to work more effectively together. |
Conclusion
By using shift left and shift right testing concepts, DevOps best practices can be integrated throughout the software development process – from coding to testing in production.
- What is Shift Left Testing
- What is Shift Right Testing
- What is Continuous Testing? Comprehensive Guide for Newbie
- What is CI/CD 101 | All You Need To Know
